There only seems to be a few people reading this blog but those that do seem to be liking it. Critics are hailing it as “better than some of the stuff I read on LiveJournal” and claiming that “it made me laugh, how bitter you are.”
My favourite response so far has been; “I like how it has no structure.” I’m hoping that this means “I like how all the posts have different topics” rather than “I like how you can’t even put words in the right order.”
As for different topics, here’s a book review.
Twilight, Stephenie Meyer (2/5)
‘Maybe that’s not the right comparison. Maybe it would be too easy to turn down the brandy. Perhaps I should have made our alcoholic a heroin addict instead.’
‘So what you’re saying is, I’m your brand of heroin?’ I teased, trying to lighten the mood.
He smiled swiftly, seeming to appreciate my effort. ‘Yes, you are exactly my brand of heroin.‘
Drugs and alcohol; we all do things we shouldn’t, things that are ultimately bad for us but make us feel good. If you’re a vampire with an unquenched bloodlust you start dating a girl who is little more than eight pints of the red stuff in a handy human shaped container. If you’re a 15-year-old girl with low self esteem and no friends, well, Stephenie Meyer’s already got you hooked on the Twilight series and it won’t be long before you’re breaking into bookshops in search of your next fix.
When I started reading this book I described it as “Girl meets vampire against backdrop of every American high school cliché ever and their non-relationship/ constant sexual subtext continues throughout the book.” and I should have stopped there. instead I’m still here looking around, at cardboard cutouts I thought were characters (someone has made a crude attempt to paint two of them), and trying not to lean against the set (it’s paper thin).
Our first cutout is Isabella Swan, the rather uninteresting and, after a while, irritating narrator who will lead us through the next 434 pages. Isabella (or Bella as she prefers to be known) used to live with her mum in Phoenix, Arizona, but has recently moved to Forks, Washington, to live with her dad. (Her mum writes some of the most inane emails I have ever read and her dad is always away fishing or policing Fork’s tiny population. Neither of these characters do much to develop the plot).
Bella is a long haired, “ivory skinned” 17-year-old who despite regularly receiving prom invites from would-be suitors considers herself unattractive.
Other aspects of Bella’s personality are equally contradictory; she is clumsy to the point of caricature and constantly in need of rescuing and yet recalls practising ballet and taking self defence classes (“Heel of the hand thrust upward, hopefully breaking the nose or shoving it into the brain. Finger through the eye socket – try to hook around and pop the eye out. And standard knee to the groin, of course.”)
Something else that doesn’t ring true is Bella’s intellect. She describes her new school book list as “fairly basic: Brontë, Shakespeare, Chaucer, Faulkner. I’d already read everything.” Bella even decides to re-read Wuthering Heights for fun and yet the closest she comes to a literary reference in the entire novel is “I made the Cowardly Lion look like the terminator.”
Surprising as it may seem, it is Bella’s mind that makes vampiric bad boy Edward Cullen fall for her and it isn’t long before sharing a table in Biology turns into something much, much more (yes, you guessed it, sharing a table in the cafeteria).
If Bella being allowed to sit at Edward’s table (a boy who she’s been warned is dangerous) makes you think “OMG! That’s like when Lindsay Lohan is invited to sit at the plastics’ table in Mean Girls.” and that thought isn’t instantly followed by a deep sense of shame then, ignore this review, you will love Twilight.
What makes a character interesting is their flawed nature, their one weakness that can completely change the course of a book. Edward lacks all of the traditional vampire flaws; he can come into contact with direct sunlight (it makes him sparkly), he can survive on only animal blood (preferably mountain lion), he doesn’t sleep in a coffin (he doesn’t even need to sleep) and he’s cool with crosses (he even has one in the family house). Stephenie Meyer has compounded this problem by giving all her vampires superhuman strength, senses and agility and then giving Edward the ability to read minds as well.
Edward’s only flaw is that he might kill Bella (either because he fails to recognise his own strength or just because he’s hungry) and this severely hampers their ability to develop the relationship. This means lots of pages of restrained kissing and mild petting which, while it may be teaching American children valuable lessons about saving themselves, is ultimately frustrating.
Maybe this predicament would have been interesting if Meyer had given us a peak into Edward’s tortured soul but instead we’re treated to unimaginative dialogue that documents the couple’s teenage temper tantrums.
Once Meyer’s caressing-the-flesh-of-a-sparkly-vampire wet dream is out the way there’s room in the book for a plot. Edward and his vampire family must protect Bella from another bunch of vampires who want to eat her. Will she survive? (Hint: this is book one in a series of four).
***
It’s been almost a thousand words and I’m beginning to get the shakes. Withdrawal symptoms are beginning to kick in and no matter how much I want to continue insulting this book my mind is consumed with an irrational desire to know more about the 2D characters and their slow moving relationship. Must read New Moon.
Related Posts
New Moon: A Remarkable Achievement
Eclipse: Now With Added Plot
Breaking Dawn: Just Say No


Recent Comments